How to Grade Your STAMPS for Maximum Value

SUBSCRIBE to our official YouTube channel “That Stamp Guy” to see more stamp videos like this, and help support the hobby of stamp collecting.

Play

Two copies of the same stamp can sell for wildly different prices, and the reason is almost always the grade. In the video above I explain how stamp grading works, what the numbers mean and how to decide whether a stamp is worth sending in. Here is the written version, with the grading scale, the gum abbreviations and the submission steps in one place.

What Is Stamp Grading?

Stamp grading is the numerical evaluation of the condition of a stamp against a set of published standards. Professional Stamp Experts (PSE) introduced a system of numerical grading for United States postage stamps in 2001. Today, this system is widely used. Grading is based on three different factors: the centering of the stamp, its soundness, and its eye appeal. The final grade is expressed as a number between 5 and 100 with 100 being a perfect stamp.

The Three Key Factors in Stamp Grading

Centering is the position of the printed image within the margins of the stamp. A grade of 100 indicates perfect centering with equal margins around the four sides of the image. Lower grades indicate off-center placement of the image within the margins of the stamp.

Soundness describes the physical integrity of the stamp. Tears, creases, thins, fading and repairs all count against soundness, and a stamp with severe faults, significant damage or alterations is normally not given a numeric grade at all.

The appearance of a stamp as to eye appeal is largely a function of color freshness, clarity of design, and in the case of used stamps, the appearance of the cancellation. A used stamp with a neat, light cancellation can actually increase the grade of the stamp while a used stamp with a heavy, design-obscuring cancellation can decrease the grade.

Understanding the Grading Scale

GradeNameWhat it means
100GemPerfect centering, flawless condition, excellent eye appeal
98SuperbNearly perfect centering
95Extremely Fine to SuperbSlightly off center under close inspection
90Extremely FineVery well centered, minor unevenness visible without magnification
85Very Fine to Extremely FineNoticeably off center compared with the higher grades
80Very FineThe standard grade, with ample margins and the design clear of the perforations
75Fine to Very FineOne or more margins approach the perforations
70 and belowFine or lowerPerforations may touch or cut into the design, and faults may be present

Some grades have a ‘J’ suffix after the grade, e.g. 98J. This means that the stamp has a ‘jumbo’ margin and is thus more attractive, and worth more, than a stamp with normal margins of the same grade.

buy sell stamps ebay hipstamp

Mint Stamps and Gum Condition Notations

An unused stamp is also described by the state of the gum. OG NH means original gum, never hinged. OG PH means original gum, previously hinged, and OG H means original gum, hinged. DOG means disturbed original gum, and RG and NG mean regummed and no gum. The Stamp Market Quarterly price guide, known as SMQ, groups unused stamps into three columns, which are never hinged, hinged with original gum, and without original gum.

How Grading Affects Stamp Value

The grade has a very large effect on price. A stamp graded Gem 100 can sell for many times the price of the same stamp graded 80, and gum condition and jumbo margins move the price further in each direction. The SMQ price guide on the PSE website, GradingMatters.com, lists an estimated value for each Scott number at each grade, so the value of a graded stamp is looked up and not guessed.

Is My Stamp Worth Grading?

A stamp with a visible or known fault is not worth submitting for a grade, because a faulty stamp will not receive one. The value after grading is weighed against the fee, since a grading fee of 30 dollars makes no sense for a stamp that is worth 20 dollars once graded. A stamp that has a fault but still has collectible or resale value can be submitted for authentication only.

Authentication vs. Grading

Authentication confirms that a stamp is genuine and describes the condition of the stamp without assigning a number, while grading adds the numeric score. Some issues need a certificate for resale whatever the condition, and the Washington-Franklin stamps are the best known example.

Accepted Grading Services

For United States and Canadian stamps the recognized services are Professional Stamp Experts (PSE), The Philatelic Foundation (PF) and Philatelic Stamp Authentication and Grading (PSAG). The video also names William Crowe, who passed away in June 2025. Each service applies its own standards and its own fee schedule, and the same stamp can receive different results from different services.

PSE Grading Submission Process

A stamp sent to PSE is placed in a rigid dealer card, and the dealer card is slipped into a thick plastic sleeve. All of the sleeves go into a zip lock bag to keep out moisture, and the bag is packed in a rigid mailer inside a padded flat rate envelope together with the submission form, which is downloaded from the PSE website. The package is sent with signature tracking and with insurance where the value warrants insurance.

At the time the video was made, the PSE fee was 5 percent of the Scott Catalogue value, with a minimum of 35 dollars for stamps issued before 1900, a minimum of 25 dollars for stamps issued after 1900 and a maximum of 600 dollars. The other services use similar fee structures. Fee schedules change, and the current schedule published by the service is the one that applies.

When to Use Other Services

If a grade comes back and looks wrong to you, you are allowed to disagree. Send the stamp to one of the other services for a second opinion, as long as the value of the stamp can carry a second fee.


Ask A Question Or Leave A Comment

stamp shop

Buy & Sell On Stamp Collectors

Find great deals, or sell stamps online.