Is This Green George Washington Stamp Really Worth A Fortune?

SUBSCRIBE to our official YouTube channel “That Stamp Guy” to see more stamp videos like this, and help support the hobby of stamp collecting.

Play

How to Identify the Rare and Valuable Scott 544 Stamp

Have you inherited a stamp collection or found an old green one-cent Washington in a drawer? Then you have probably read about a stamp worth $35,000. It is the real deal and in the video above I show you exactly what to look for on a Scott 544. Here is the same check but written out in full, and also the two most common stamps that people mistake for the Scott 544 on a daily basis.



What Scott 544 Is

Scott 544 is a green one-cent United States postage stamp showing George Washington, and Scott 544 belongs to the Washington-Franklin series. To the eye Scott 544 looks the same as several other one-cent green Washington stamps, including Scott 498 and Scott 538, which are common. Scott 544 is separated from the common stamps by two measurements, which are the perforation gauge and the size of the printed design.

The perforation gauge comes first

Perforation gauge is a count of the perforation holes along the edge of a stamp, and the perforation gauge of Scott 544 is 11 on all four sides. The measurement is taken with a perforation gauge tool, by sliding the stamp along the tool until the black dots printed on the tool line up exactly with the perforation holes of the stamp. Every side is measured separately, because some one-cent green Washington stamps carry mixed perforations. A stamp that measures 11 on two sides and 10 on the other two sides is not Scott 544.

The design measurement decides it

The second measurement is the size of the printed design, which means the inked image only and not the stamp from perforation tip to perforation tip. According to the Scott catalog, the design of Scott 544 measures 19 millimeters wide by 22.5 millimeters high. An ordinary ruler is not accurate enough for the measurement, because the differences between Scott 544 and the common stamps are a fraction of a millimeter. A perforation gauge tool with a transparent fine-scale ruler is laid directly over the printed design, and the width and the height are each read twice.

buy sell stamps ebay hipstamp

The Stamps That Get Mistaken for Scott 544

Scott 498 is the stamp most often mistaken for Scott 544. Scott 498 is also perforated 11, so Scott 498 passes the perforation test, but the design of Scott 498 measures 22.25 millimeters high and not 22.5 millimeters high. That quarter of a millimeter is the whole difference, and Scott 498 is worth a few cents to a few dollars.

The Scott 538 is a close relative, but it fails the perforation test. This stamp is found with mixed perforations, 11 on some sides and 10 on the other sides. A mint example of the Scott 538 is worth only a few dollars.



A Matching Stamp Still Needs a Certificate

The fact that a stamp measures up to the dimensions of a Scott 544 is not proof that the stamp is indeed a Scott 544. A Scott 486 can be altered to look like a Scott 544 by reperforating the four sides of the stamp. Many of these fakes are so good that only an expert after detailed analysis can tell the difference between the original and the fake. At tens of thousands of dollars for a single stamp, the buyer wants a certificate of authenticity from a reputable expertizing service and the seller wants to get full price for the stamp.

Why the Washington-Franklin Series Is So Hard

The Washington-Franklin series of United States stamps is the most complicated series of stamps to collect. There are so many different catalog numbers for so few designs. Each stamp is identified by its perforation, by its method of printing, and by various measurements of the design on the stamp. The Expert’s Book to the Washington-Franklin Series by Paul Schmidt is a specialist reference for this series. The book deals with identification of the stamps, those most frequently faked, and with detailed measurements and with markings on the stamps. This very scarce book often sells for over $100 but is a small investment for the serious collector of this series.



Finding Treasure Among Common Stamps

Most green one-cent Washington stamps are common and most of those that look like Scott 544 will turn out to be Scott 498 or Scott 538. It is still worth taking the five minutes to measure as a real Scott 544 is a life changing find.

Happy collecting! If you want more of this, I have other articles and videos on identifying rare stamps, spotting fakes and finding treasure in unexpected places.


3 responses to “Is This Green George Washington Stamp Really Worth A Fortune?”

  1. Rebecca

    Hi there, I found an old book in my grandmothers house . She has some George Washington stamps and I was wondering if the 1cent 544 was always perforated on all sides? She dated it underneath the stamp 1918? Does that also sound accurate? I know there is more to the ID of this rare stamp. Thank you for your time and effort to help.

  2. Francis

    Is there other stamps having the same measures?

    1. Ryan Joneson

      Great question, Francis. Yes, several stamps in the Washington-Franklin series come close to the Scott 544’s design measurements (19mm x 22.5mm), which is exactly what makes this series so tricky. Design size alone won’t tell you which stamp you have. You also need to check the perforation gauge (11 for the 544, and watch out for mixed perforations on some lookalikes), since those small differences separate a $35,000 stamp from one worth just a few dollars. If you have a specific stamp you’re trying to pin down, a perforation gauge tool is the best investment you can make. Happy collecting!

Ask A Question Or Leave A Comment

stamp shop

Buy & Sell On Stamp Collectors

Find great deals, or sell stamps online.