People have been counterfeiting postage stamps for almost 200 years, ever since the first ones were issued in 1840. There are many ways to use a fake stamp, from cheating the mail system to making money off of collectors. In the above video I run through a list of warning signs that I use to determine if a stamp is genuine or not, starting with modern Forever stamps and working back to the classics. This page contains the same list of checks in writing.
Modern Stamps: The Counterfeit Forever Stamp Problem
The U.S. Postal Inspection Service notes that counterfeit stamps are often sold in bulk quantities at a significant discount, anywhere from 20 to 50 percent of face value. According to the same Postal Inspection Service notice, the Postal Service does not sell stamps for less than face value. Therefore, any listing for Forever stamps for sale below face value on any marketplace or social media platform is considered to be counterfeit until proven otherwise.
According to the Postal Inspection Service, fake stamps are sold on many different social media marketplaces as well as on various e-commerce sites through third-party sellers. Stamps sold by vendors located outside of the U.S. are more than likely counterfeit. The only exceptions are big box and warehouse retailers that sell stamps through resale agreements with the U.S. Postal Service, for small discounts, and these are not sold as rolls of Forever stamps for half price.
The Postal Inspection Service notice states that purchasing or using counterfeit postage is illegal, and that mail carrying counterfeit postage is considered abandoned and can be opened and disposed of at the discretion of the Postal Service. The safe sources named in the notice are the Postal Service itself and the Approved Postal Providers listed by the Postal Service. Counterfeit stamps of the modern kind are a mail fraud problem, and a collector has no reason to own them.
Fake and Altered Collectible Stamps Are a Different Problem
Most fraudulent activity in the world of collectible stamps does not involve making a “new” stamp. Rather, the majority of the fraud is accomplished by altering an existing (genuine) stamp in such a manner as to create the appearance of a much more rare and valuable stamp. There are three types of alteration that represent almost all of what can be found on classic United States material: reperforation (changing or adding perforations), regumming (re-gumming with new gum to simulate the original gum), and cancellation removal (washing or lightening a postmark so that a used stamp looks like it has never been used). For stamps produced during the 19th century and early 20th century, any of these alterations will materially change the value of the stamp.
Why the Washington-Franklin Issues Attract So Many Fakes
The Washington-Franklin definitives of 1908 to 1922 are the most heavily faked area of United States philately, because dozens of catalog numbers share a handful of designs and the differences between the catalog numbers are technical. Perforation gauge, watermark, printing method and design dimensions separate a common stamp from a scarce stamp, and the price gap between the common stamp and the scarce stamp can be several thousand dollars. That price gap is the reason altered stamps concentrate in this series.
The alteration seen most often is the manufactured coil. A coil stamp has two straight edges and two perforated edges, so trimming the perforations from two sides of an ordinary sheet stamp produces something that looks like a coil at first glance. Where the genuine coil is rare, the trimmed sheet stamp is offered as the rare coil.
A Four-Point Check for Flat Plate Washington-Franklin Coils
Measure the design
Flat plate printings and rotary press printings of the same design differ slightly in the dimensions of the printed design, because the curved plate of the rotary press stretched the design in one direction. A reliable multi-gauge is laid against the design and the measurement is read, since a measurement is more dependable than an impression of size. When the design measures as a rotary press printing, the trimming trick is not in play, because trimming a stamp cannot turn a rotary press design into a flat plate design.
Measure the whole stamp from edge to edge
Where the design measures as a flat plate printing, the full stamp is measured from one straight edge to the other straight edge. Known dimensions for each orientation exist for genuine flat plate coils; thus, stamps wider or longer than these known dimensions have likely been cut down from fully perforated sheet stamps.
Examine the perforation holes under magnification
The opposite has also been done with some rare coils, i.e. perforations have been added to an imperforate stamp. Under the highest magnification the perforations on a stamp made during production will show some irregularities and some disturbance to the fibers of the paper around the edges of the holes. Holes added later are too cleanly made, too sharp and too uniform to have been made during production. They can be made with a homemade punch or even with a sewing machine.
Examine the straight edges
Coils produced as genuine items were stored as rolled material. This material has been handled as rolls with the straight edges of the stamps being slightly soft when viewed under a magnifying glass, often with signs of wear to one edge. Blade cut edges produced recently can look very crisp and ‘new’. Stamps with two straight edges that both look very sharp should be treated with suspicion.
Even passing all of these tests does not guarantee authenticity. Many skilled alterations can pass each test; therefore, collectors of expensive classics such as flat plate coils often purchase them with a certificate from a recognized expertizing service, and serious collectors will not invest real dollars into an item unless it has been certified by an expert.
Reperforating Hides More Than Poor Centering
Reperforating stamps is done to better center stamps. However, reperforating also removes any evidence of damage to the stamp such as small tears, stains or thins near the previous perforations. Stamps that are poorly centered may have been reperforated for that reason and therefore poor centering does not prove that the perforations are original.
Why Unused Classic Stamps Deserve Extra Suspicion
All of the stamps from the 1800’s were produced for the purpose of carrying mail. Therefore, most of them were used. Unused examples of many of the classic stamps are scarcer and more expensive than used examples. Many people try to remove cancellations from used stamps. A stamp with a light cancellation on one edge is often the subject of attempts to remove the cancellation. Some of the historical inks are soluble in water. Many pen cancellations can be lightened. Under magnification one can see slight traces of ink, discoloration of the paper fibers, and an uneven tone in the area where the cancellation was washed out.
Regumming Is the Most Misunderstood Alteration
The premium placed on original gum by collectors of classic stamps created an incentive to manufacture gum for stamps. Collectors often mounted unused stamps by licking them and sticking them to album pages. Dealers also displayed stamps in ways that would be considered destructive today. When stamps were removed from album pages, the original gum was often left behind. This led to a large amount of regumming of stamps to create stamps that appeared to be mint.
The perforation tips of a stamp that has been regummed can be examined with a magnifier of 10 power or higher. Stamps that have been separated from a sheet in normal fashion have torn perforation tips with tiny loose paper fibers and a soft texture. The regumming gum will soak into the tips of the regummed stamp making the tips appear smooth and sealed with no loose fibers.
A regummed stamp is not necessarily worthless. There are many stamps on the market today that have been regummed, some even without any gum at all. When these are correctly described and offered for sale at the right price, they can still have value. It becomes fraud when such a stamp is offered for sale as having original gum.
What to Do With a Stamp That Might Be Valuable
The reason that a potentially rare stamp isn’t sold for a lot of money without certification is that there are so many advanced collectors who recognize the patterns of the uncertified copies in the higher price range and stay away from them. The certification process is explained in detail on our stamp certification page. For identification of Washington-Franklin stamps there are specialized reference books which go into much more detail than the normal catalog and contain information on which stamps are most frequently faked, and which common stamps are used as a basis for fakes. These specialized reference books can be rare and cost more than normal collector’s books.
Before you pay an expertizing fee, get experienced eyes on the stamp first. Post clear photos of the front and back in our collectors community, with close-ups of the perforations, the edges and any spot where a cancel might have been, and people who handle this material every week will tell you whether it looks worth submitting. Buy modern postage only from legitimate sources, slow down around measurements, perforations, edges, gum and cancels on the classics, and you will avoid most of the expensive mistakes.




















Ask A Question Or Leave A Comment