Welcome to the Stamp Collectors Community! Ask stamp collecting questions like identification, values, and more. If you have questions regarding buying and selling in the Stamp Collectors Stamp Shop part of our website, visit our main Support page.
By participating in this community, you agree to all of the community guidelines and policies.
Hello Everyone.
My name is Jim and I live in Central California. I have 2 stamps that sre almost identical. I don’t have a perforation gauge so I am unable to check the count myself. Gemini and CoPilot both give me conflicting answers. Please note my grid is 25 x 25 pixels for each square. Gemini Tells me the top stamp is E12 and CoPilot tells me the bottom stamp is E12. Any help would be greatly apporeciated
@california-kid Welcome to the Stamp Collectors Community.
This first image upon your Post is US Scott # E12, Gray Violet, Unwatermarked, Perforation 11, Issued on July 12th, 1922. CV Unused $45.00.
If you utilize other Catalogues in lieu of Scott, here are the most popular Catalogues out there along with this stamp’s Cat # for your reference…
Michel # 258IAb
Stanley Gibbons # E648
Yvert et Tellier # E9
The second upon your Post is US Scott # E12a, Deep or Dark Ultramarine, Unwatermarked, Perforation 11, also Issued on July 12th, 1922. CV Unused $55.00.
If you utilize other Catalogues in lieu of Scott, here are the most popular Catalogues out there along with this stamp’s Cat # for your reference…
Michel # 258IAa
Stanley Gibbons # E559
Yvert et Tellier # E9b
I hope the above information proves helpful to your needs, and has inspired you to keep on collecting stamps.
Jan M. Blaha
APS# 238933
@california-kid searching further, if the color varieties of the stamp presented upon your Post are MNH (Mint No [Never] Hinged) the respective CV (Catalogue Value) would be as follows:
E12 = $95.00
E12a = $130.00
Usually such stamps, in good condition with no faults can sell for 60% CV.
This does not consider CV when taking Grade into account. I myself do not use this aspect of Grading for CV personally, I am old school (I use Avg., F, F-VF, VF-XF, and XF). But @ryanjoneson is quite familiar with this facet of US Stamps valuation.
Jan M. Blaha
APS# 238933
Thank you everyone. That sure helps
@california-kid This the same stamp as shown upon your initial Post. However, instead of a single stamp, this is a Plate # Block of 4 stamps (Plate # 19280).
Therefore, the specifics are the same as noted upon your initial Post with the exception of the CV – see below…
US Scott # E12, Gray Violet, Unwatermarked, Perforation 11, Issued on July 12th, 1922. This Block’s centering is a “F” (Fine) in my opinion.
Scott Specialized Catalogue of United States Postage Stamps and Covers 2025 has a listing for a Plate # Block of 6 at a CV Unused for the sum of $ 525.00 Hinged, and $800 Unhinged. There is no listing for a Plate # Block of 4.
I would say to divide the above noted CVs by 6, then multiply by 4 to get a CV for a Block of 4. But I do not believe this is a correct Philatelic way to formulaically come to an adjusted CV for a Plate # Block of 4 from a 6.
Personally, this is what I have done when I encounter such a quandary and hope it is a viable CV solution.
With this stated, the CV Hinged would be $350.00, and CV Unhinged would be 533.33 (rounding down to $530.00).
Maybe someone else in the Stamp Collector’s Community can provide some input on just such a quandary, please do so. I would like to know whether my above noted solution is sound or am I deluding myself?
I hope the above somewhat proves helpful CV-wise.
Jan M. Blaha
APS# 238933
Hello Jan
Thank you very much. It helps out a lot. I am still a newbie when it comes to stamp collecting but, I am learning. I have been collecting for about 7 month now. I had no idea that block was an E12. I listened to Google Gemini and the other AIs and they all gave me conflicting details on the Scott#. Atleast here in the community I can get the correct information
Thank you
Jim from California
Great work on these @jblaha, and thanks for the shout out. On grading: Scott values assume Very Fine, so a Fine centered copy like this one usually sells under catalogue. Graded copies (PSE or PF certs with a numeric grade) are priced off the grade instead.
On the plate block question, your math is a fair starting point, but I would lean lower. Collectors want the full Plate Block of 6 for these flat plate issues, so a block of 4 with the number usually trades closer to four singles plus a small premium for the plate number.
@california-kid welcome aboard, and good call checking here instead of trusting the AI apps.
APS Stamp Dealer #224675
@california-kid Jim, I must ask – How are you storing these nice finds? Just curious.
You do not want to write any annotations (e.g. Scott #, year, etc.) upon the reverse side of the stamp. Doing such drastically effects the CV, and is now frowned upon by collectors worldwide.
I have been collecting for 55+ years now, and have a vast abundance of such stamps, with annotations upon the reverse side – this was a common practice back in the past by many collectors.
I would recommend utilizing a Vario Sheets to store you mints stamps, so they are well protected. And to have a small piece of paper (1″ x 1″) placed adjacent to the stamp in question with such annotations (e.g. Scott Catalogues #, year of issue, CV, and condition & grade).
Grade annotations can be noted as (this is done by eye, as I do <or> to acquire a Certificate from PSE at a service cost). Below are the recommended abbreviations to annotate Grade…
Average (Avg) = the stamps image hits the perforations.
Fine (F) = the stamps image is clear of the perforations, but a tad off center.
Fine to Very Fine (F-VF) = similar to Fine above, but with a better centering.
Very Fine (VF) = the image is well centered, and fully clear of being near any perforations – As @ryanjoneson stated upon his Reply Post, this is the centering of which Scott Catalogues quotes their CVs upon.
Extremely Fine (XF) = the stamps image is virtually perfectly centered.
and finally Superb (S) = the stamps image is exquisitely centered.
Condition or Gum can be noted as follows:
MNH = Mint No (Never) Hinged
MH = Mint Hinged
MHR = Mint Hint Remnant (do not try to remove the remnant, you may damage the stamp)
MNG = Mint No Gum
NGAI = No Gum As Issued
There are others but the above is the basic ones used for mint condition stamps. You can get more information on all aspects of stamp collecting from various sites – I would guide you to check out this link…
Check out the “Library” Section on this site.
In addition, as mentioned by @ryanjoneson Grading can provide you with an enhanced CV. Recent issues of Scott Specialized Catalogues of United States Postage Stamps and Cover provide a section listing the above Grades along with the enhanced CV for each US Scott #. I know not whence this new section was introduced.
@ryanjoneson Thank you for the clarification on my math quandary. With this stated, what would you say the premium percentage-wise should be tacked on? Please advise.
Jan M. Blaha
APS# 238933
@california-kid Jim, you can also check out @ryanjoneson‘s Youtube Channel this is a good place to learn more about stamp collecting. Ryan’s Channel is @ThatStampGuy
Jan M. Blaha
APS# 238933
Hello all.
I checked the plate number on that block of 4 and it is an E15 not an E12.
@california-kid – Nice catch – I have forgotten about this Search Tool within the Stamp Smarter site.
Since this Block of 4 is a US Scott # E15, Perforation 11×10.5, Issued on November 29th, 1927.
With this stated I would recommend you check the Perforations on the two single stamps you presented upon your initial Post. If they are Perforation 11 then they are both an E12. If not, and you find either of them to be Perforation 11×10.5, then they are an E15.
If the second single upon you Initial Post is found to be Perf 11×10.5 it would be a Color Changeling, since E15 does not list a Deep/Dark Ultramarine for this Scott #.
Unfortunately, the CVs for E15 are not as lucrative as they are for E12, but it does specifically list a Block of 4 = $6.50 (Hinged) and $10.50 (Unhinged).
Thank you for reminding me about this Seach Tool within the Stamp Smarter site.
Jan M. Blaha
APS# 238933
Nice catch on the E15 @california-kid, and thanks @jblaha for the shout out on the channel.
Jim, that perforation check Jan described is the right next step for your two singles. A perforation gauge is cheap and worth having for exactly this kind of question. Since this one turned out to be an E15, please ignore the E12 plate block numbers from my earlier reply.
APS Stamp Dealer #224675























