Why These Stamps Are Now Worth BIG MONEY

SUBSCRIBE to our official YouTube channel “That Stamp Guy” to see more stamp videos like this, and help support the hobby of stamp collecting.

Play

Ryan here from StampCollectors.us. My latest batch of graded stamp certificates came back from Professional Stamp Experts (PSE), and this post goes through the results. It was a small submission of 12 items, but several of the items are worth a closer look.

If you’re new to stamp grading or curious about how it works, refer to this video.




Submission Overview

The submission held 12 items. The processing time was about 45 days. The values come from GradingMatters.com, which publishes the SMQ values of the Stamp Market Quarterly. The stamps are sold in the US Stamp Shop on Facebook.


Scott #4: Graded VF 80 (No Gum As Issued)

The stamp is sound with four clear margins. The SMQ value is 14 dollars. I expect a sale at about 11 dollars, which is 80 percent of the SMQ value.

Scott 4 is an early imperforate stamp, and this example has the centering of a true very fine stamp. The value is modest, but collectors still want Scott 4 with a certificate.


Scott #10: Graded VF 80, Used

The color is orange brown and the stamp is Type I. The faults are a small corner crease and a laminated thin. The SMQ value is 200 dollars.

The crease and the thin did not take away much of the market value, because the margins on this stamp are large. The stamp has the look of an extremely fine example, and I think the grade would have been higher without the fault.


Scott #367: Graded XF 90, Never Hinged

The SMQ value is 45 dollars. The certificate cost about 30 dollars.

The certificate cost about 30 dollars against an SMQ value of 45 dollars, so the submission was a wash and not a profit. The centering is excellent, and the stamp suits a collector who wants high grade stamps from the early 1900s.


Scott #404: Graded VF-XF 85, Used

The stamp is the Pan-Pacific issue in perf 10. The SMQ value is 120 dollars.

The perf 10 Pan-Pacific stamps are known for poor centering, and this example is well centered for the issue. A grade of 90 would have carried a value of 200 dollars, but an 85 is still a used example that collectors of the 1913 Pan-Pacific series want.


Scott #427: Graded XF 90, Used

The cancel is a sock on the nose strike from San Francisco dated June 1916. The SMQ value is 40 dollars.

The centering is beautiful and the cancel is attractive, but PSE did not add the J for jumbo margins and did not add a bonus for the cancel. The stamp still belongs in a premium collection.


Scott #501: Graded Superb 98, Never Hinged

The SMQ value is 500 dollars.

Scott 501 is a common stamp that is worth a few dollars in ordinary condition. This example is centered almost perfectly, and the centering alone accounts for the value of 500 dollars.


Scott #610a: Imperf Pair Error (Verified)

The pair is an imperforate pair variety. The Scott listing is 610a. The catalogue value is 2,000 dollars.

PSE confirmed the pair as a genuine Scott 610a error. The left margin of the pair was trimmed, but the error status is verified and the pair keeps its value as a rare item.


buy sell stamps ebay hipstamp

Scott #619: Graded VF-XF 85, Never Hinged

The SMQ value is 35 dollars.

This is a good looking stamp that fell short of 90, the grade at which the value rises sharply. At 85 the stamp fits a mid-range collection.


Scott #634: Dark Carmine Shade (Not 634A)

The stamp was not recognized as Scott 634A. The result adds nothing to the catalogue value.

This result was a disappointment. PSE did not confirm the stamp as the valuable carmine lake variety, and I am keeping the stamp as a reference for future comparison.


Scott #715: Graded XF-Sup 95, Never Hinged

The SMQ value is 40 dollars.

The centering is beautiful, but the stamp missed the grade of 98, which would have raised the value to 160 dollars. The stamp is still a sharp example from the Washington Bicentennial set.


Scott #C14: Graded Superb 98J, Previously Hinged

The stamp is the 1.30 dollar Graf Zeppelin. The SMQ value is 1,100 dollars.

This was the best result of the submission. The J for jumbo margins raises the value well above the value of a typical very fine example.


Scott #RW39: Graded XF-Sup 95, Never Hinged

The stamp was issued in 1972. The SMQ value is 120 dollars.

A modern duck stamp rarely brings a high premium unless the stamp is close to perfect, and this stamp shows how much the grade matters on a newer issue. A grade of 100 would have put the value at 450 dollars.

This batch had some gambles, some premium stamps and some lessons. A few stamps graded where I expected, a few let me down, and a few came back better than I hoped. If you are thinking about stamp grading, that is both the risk and the reward.

For weekly premium listings, join the US Stamp Shop on Facebook, where I post 75+ U.S. graded stamps every week. Until next time, best of luck and happy collecting


One response to “Why These Stamps Are Now Worth BIG MONEY”

  1. bobby smith

    I have a lot of 2 cent 3 cent stamps that I know nothing about. I would like to know if they have value before i dispose of them.. thank you

Ask A Question Or Leave A Comment

stamp shop

Buy & Sell On Stamp Collectors

Find great deals, or sell stamps online.