My Final Submission to William Crowe: Rare U.S. Stamps Examined

SUBSCRIBE to our official YouTube channel “That Stamp Guy” to see more stamp videos like this, and help support the hobby of stamp collecting.

Play

UPDATE: Unfortunately we lost a philatelic gem. William Crowe, the stamp expertizer, passed away on June 22, 2025. These are the last stamps I sent to him.

This was my latest submission to William Crowe. I normally use PSE when I want a stamp graded, but I preferred to send certain stamps to Crowe for authentication and a condition opinion. Any of the five major certification services will keep you on the right track. If stamp certification is new to you, I covered the basics in an earlier video. The stamps below were offered in my Facebook group, US Stamp Shop, where I post 75 premium U.S. stamps every week. Here is what came back.



Scott 62B: Often Confused, But Far More Valuable

This is a scarce 10¢ stamp that is often confused with the more common Scott 68. The difference between the two is that Scott 62B has an incomplete upper frame line around the words U.S. Postage. The stamp in this submission was certified genuine. It has a very lightly struck red cancel and two small thins in the hinged area. At first glance the stamp almost appears to be unused.

Scott 64: The Halloween Cancel

Scott 64 is the pink shade of the 3 cent design of 1861, as distinct from the common rose shade, Scott 65, which has little value ungraded. The stamp was certified as the genuine pink shade. The stamp carries a nicely struck cancel of Kalamazoo, Michigan dated October 31, which makes the stamp a Halloween cancel, and the stamp is sound, with fine to very fine centering and no faults.

Scott 70B: Identifying Steel Blue Isn’t Easy

Scott 70B is the steel blue shade of the 24 cent design of 1861, a recognized variety that is notoriously hard to identify. The White color guide helps, although experience with the shade is the better teacher. Some examples of the ordinary Scott 70 have been chemically altered to resemble steel blue, and the test is the tone of the blue: genuine steel blue is grayish and not greenish. The stamp in this submission was certified genuine with faults, namely a sealed tear at the top and corner creases at the left, and the stamp remains a collectible copy in spite of the faults.

F Grill Cover: Not Tied, But Still Interesting

The submission included a cover bearing three 1 cent F grill stamps, a pair and a single. The three stamps were certified genuine, but the stamps are not tied to the cover, meaning that the cancel does not run from the stamps onto the envelope. Without a tying cancel there is no proof that the stamps were on the envelope when the envelope went through the mail, so stamps of this kind are generally valued as used stamps off cover. The stamps on this cover also have some perforation flaws.

buy sell stamps ebay hipstamp

1¢ H Grill: Faint Grill, Mint with Gum

The 1 cent H grill in this submission is unused with original gum, and the grill impression is very faint. The certificate describes the stamp as genuine and sound. The centering is not good, but an unused grilled stamp with original gum is a solid stamp for a collector of the grilled issues.

Scott 139: The Split Grill Variety

Scott 139, the 10 cent H grill, came back as a genuine example of the split grill variety, on which the grill is shifted far enough to be divided by the perforations. The certificate notes a short perforation at the bottom left and no other faults. A recognized variety of this kind adds to the value of the stamp.

Scott 459 Pair: Imperforate Coil, Gum Condition Matters

Scott 459 is an imperforate coil, which was issued without perforations and had to be cut apart by hand. The pair was certified genuine with original gum. The right stamp of the pair is never hinged and the left stamp is previously hinged, and because never hinged and previously hinged stamps are priced differently, the pair may be worth more offered as two single stamps than offered as a pair.

Scott 500: Deep Rose with a Flaw

Scott 500 is a deep rose Type Ia. This is a genuinely used example with a light cancel and fine to very fine centering. The certificate notes that the stamp has been reperforated at the bottom. This would reduce the resale value of the stamp.

Scott 519: Commonly Faked but This One’s Genuine

Scott 519 is frequently faked by adding perforations to the imperforate version of the stamp. This stamp was certified as genuine, unused, with original gum, previously hinged. This matters greatly on a stamp that is faked so frequently.

Scott 315 Single: Never Hinged and Graded

This Scott 315 stamp is a 5 cent imperforate. It was certified as genuine, never hinged, and given a grade of 90 (extremely fine). This grade greatly increases the SMQ value of this stamp. It is very frequently faked by cutting the perforations off a Scott 304 with wide margins. Therefore, a certificate of authenticity is very important when buying a single stamp.

Scott 315 Pair: Certified and Graded

The submission also included a pair of Scott 315 stamps. Unlike a single stamp, a pair cannot be trimmed to make it look like something else, so it is easier to verify authenticity of a pair. The stamps were certified as genuine with a grade of 90. The stamps were signed in pencil on the back by Herbert J. Block, which was common on older stamps and does not usually affect the gum or value of the stamps.

Scott 447: Graded 90, But Off-Center

Scott 447 is a 5 cent flat plate coil of the Washington-Franklin series, one of the most commonly faked groups of United States stamps, and coils of the series should always be certified. The pair came back genuine and never hinged with a grade of 90. To my eye the pair is noticeably off center at the right and looks closer to very fine than to extremely fine. Grading a multiple is subjective, and I judge a multiple by the centering around the perimeter, so I would price this pair nearer to SMQ 85 than to the XF 90 on the certificate. A collector who disagrees with a grade can resubmit the stamp or ask a different certification service for a second opinion.

If these stamps interest you, come visit US Stamp Shop on Facebook. Until next time, best of luck and happy collecting.


Ask A Question Or Leave A Comment

stamp shop

Buy & Sell On Stamp Collectors

Find great deals, or sell stamps online.