These Stamps Are Worth THOUSANDS

SUBSCRIBE to our official YouTube channel “That Stamp Guy” to see more stamp videos like this, and help support the hobby of stamp collecting.

Play

Every so often a stamp that looks ordinary turns out to be worth thousands, and the only way to prove it is a certificate. In the video above I open a batch of certificates that came back from the experts and go through what each stamp turned out to be. This page summarizes the stamps and the lessons, because the same handful of features, shades, grills and coils, are the ones worth sending in from your own collection. If rare stamps are an investment for you, this is where the money is made or lost.

Why Authentication is Necessary

Many valuable stamps are almost identical to common stamps. In addition, there are many counterfeits and altered stamps on the market today. A seller who is convinced that a stamp is the rare variety must have it certified before selling it at a premium to a serious buyer. The certificate must confirm that the stamp is indeed of the variety claimed, that it is in the condition stated (even a minor fault can have a big impact on the value of a rare stamp) and that it has not been altered in order to deceive the buyer into thinking it is a rarer stamp than it actually is.

Examining Rare Stamps: Case Studies

Scott 22 in the submission is the Type IIIa variety, and the example shows a curl in the hair, a plate variety that is not noted in the standard catalog listing. The cancel on the stamp is light, which leaves the design and the variety clearly visible and makes the stamp more desirable.

Scott 27 is a Type I in the brick red color. It carries a New Orleans town cancel. Brick red is one of those colors that are hard to determine for certain without the expert opinion. The colors on these old stamps have changed somewhat with age. The certificate is what assures the buyer that the color is correct. Scott 28b is the bright red brown color of the same Type I design. It was returned as genuine but reperforated horizontally. It is interesting to see the two different colors of the same design side by side. There is not much difference in the color but there is a big difference in value.

buy sell stamps ebay hipstamp

The Importance of Grills in Stamps

A grill is a pattern of small points embossed into the paper of a stamp. Grilled stamps are among the most frequently faked and altered United States stamps because a grill can be added to an ungrilled stamp long after it was issued. Scott 85, the 3 cent D grill, came back genuine with minor flaws and a genuine D grill is scarce and collectible even with flaws. Scott 99, the 24 cent F grill, is another grill that calls for expert examination because counterfeits are common. A further F grill stamp in the batch carries a red cancel, which adds a premium, although the grill area shows minor imperfections.

Submitting Stamps for Certification

Stamps are sent to an expertizing service and then returned. Most services charge a flat fee plus a percentage of the value of the stamps as listed in the catalogue. The stamps in this video were sent to the late William Crowe. Stamps that are worth sending for expertizing are those that are believed to be of rare shades, grills etc. Information such as the type of cancel and the centering is noted before sending the stamps.

Evaluating Graded Stamps

A numeric grade adds a second piece of information to a certificate by describing centering and condition on a scale. Scott 404, from the Pan-Pacific issue, came back graded 80, which is very fine, and never hinged. Scott 476 came back graded 80 with original gum. A grade is a position on the grading scale and not a percentage of catalog value, and the market value of a graded stamp is looked up for that grade.

Tips for Identifying Rare Stamps

Catalog numbers of similar designs and shades are first identified. Stamps are checked for defects such as thins, creases and tears. The cancel on a stamp is also checked as unusual cancels can add value to a stamp. All coils, in particular flat plate coils, are sent for certification as many are faked by trimming the perforations of sheet stamps.

Coil Waste and Unique Features

The Scott 545 is a coil waste issue. It was printed on the rotary press for coils and then perforated on all four sides to make sheet stamps. Thus, for coil waste stamps a certificate is normally expected.

Conclusion

Most of the stamps in any collection are ordinary. The ones that are not tend to give themselves away through a shade, a grill, a cancel or a coil, and those are the ones worth the certification fee. Learn what to look for, send in the candidates, and let the certificate do the arguing for you. Happy collecting!


Ask A Question Or Leave A Comment

stamp shop

Buy & Sell On Stamp Collectors

Find great deals, or sell stamps online.